Cases of suspect gastroenteritis
Hi,
This problem had occurred to me when I first did th GR 20 north some ten years ago ( I suffered from a light case of dysentery between Col de Vergio and Mananu).
This time though it struck me the night I slept at Manganu. I threw up 4 times, felt nausea and wasn't able to eat for the following 48 hours!!! Plus after a day of complete rest at Manganu, the following day (when I resumed my trek) some virulent dysentery made my day miserable.
The day I stayed at Manganu I asked around, and found out that I was not alone in this. Other people had had vomit the night before and other had suffered from dysentery as well.
We tried to pinpoint the origin, but everybody had eaten different food so ... could it be the water?
After reading some literature about gastroenteritis I learned that the sickness manifests itself at least 24 hours after contagion. So I wonder if this issue is localized at Vergio or thereabout.
People don't seem to attribute much importance to this problem (or probably don't like to write about it), so I couldn't find any other threads on this forum.
Still I wonder if this is a case to raise a flag. What do you think?
Any other reports?
Thank you
--Michele
Posted: Thu, Jul 22, 2010, 21:34
Michele,
YES! It's a common complaint around that area. I was sick myself, and it was certainly water-borne since we carried and cooked our own food. We generally treated all water with iodine, but got sloppy ... and got stung as a result. I spoke to many others passing in both directions (half-pun intended ...), and got similar reports.
Mountain streams sure look clean and fresh, but if grazing and/or human accommodation is happening upstream ... treat the water!!
I second your comment that people do not seem to report this on the forum, and it puzzles me as to why not.
Mike
Posted: Fri, Jul 23, 2010, 10:34
Hi Mike,
Thanks for your reply.
Are you saying that people travelling south to north also had this problem? The point is the night I had vomit was after I arrived from Col de Verghio where I filled my tank and I didn't drink any water from the Manganu area (nor did I make a stop at Berg. de Vaccaghja). So if we rule out food (at Manganu I had charcuterie, omelette and beer) I can only assume the origin might be in Col de Verghio.
And when I left Manganu for Pietrapiana I had filled my tank with water from the source but treated it with enough iodine to be on the safe side (and let it rest for many hours before drinking).
So if we could have more reports it would be extremely helpful. This issue does NOT seem to be random nor sporadic.
And it would help a lot of trekkers.
So, c'mon people!!!
---Michele
Posted: Fri, Jul 23, 2010, 14:21
Michele,
Yes. To be specific, we camped at the Hotel Castel di Verghio (where our tent was attacked and ruined by foxes!) and used the "new" shower and toilet block, drawing water from the taps there. Relishing the prospect of non-iodine-treated water, we drank it from the tap.
We had met a woman, travelling Northbound, between Mori and Auberge Vallone who warned us about foxes at HCdV (what the hell was she talking about???!!!) and several people sick at Manganu. Confirmed from chatting to others coming from South.
We arrived at HCdV in the afternoon, and stayed until lunchtime, trying to repair the tent and deciding to bail and rest up. :-( getting a hitch-hike down the valley. We started feeling ill then.
Next day, we were properly ill, and it lasted 48 hours. A Dutch couple who stayed at HCdV same time were also ill.
So, I think your suggestion is probably spot on.
Still, I'd go back and do it again!
Posted: Fri, Jul 23, 2010, 16:48
Mike,
So you drank it from the tap on the new shower and toilet block of HCdV!!! That's it. I did the same. And so many other people, taking for granted that water was perfectly ok.
Of course we don't have any evidence of this, this is just a suspect .. so we can't positively say: be careful, that water is infected. But still ... a word of caution is in order.
This might/will help those forum readers preparing for this trek, to take this into account and use iodine tablets, katadine products, steripen or whatever to treat that water ..... JUST IN CASE.
Thanks for your feedback.
Ps
And no doubt I too, if I could, would be back on the trail tomorrow :)))
Posted: Sat, Jul 24, 2010, 21:07
Hi Michele, we did the GR 20 in Sept 2008 and all was fab till day after MANGANU at PETRA PIANA where i was very sick in the night along with several other people, the morning after i felt drained, i ended up going down for 2 days to recover(my wife and friend staying on island and had a car)they picked me up at Canaglia. I went back up to re join my friend at CAPANELLE and when he arrived he had had it too.(he is much fitter than me and managed to carry on but had been very ill) we both set off from CAPANELLE the morning after fit and had a fab finish to the rest of the walk. The Gardian at CAPANELLE had taken some people to hospital the day before and he said it was the water at MANGANU that had caused the problems. we have since walked the MARE E MONTI and treated all our water with ultra violet light and steralizing tablets and had no problems at all. so to some it up please take steralizing tablets and treat all your water. hope this helps.
Steve.
Posted: Sun, Jul 25, 2010, 7:01
Thanks for your contribution Steve. The more reports we get, the better.
I don't really understand why this issue is not openly disclosed. A placard in the suspect areas should be enough to warn trekkers of potential contamination.
There is a slack kind of approach to this by the locals who should be very well informed.
Even the lady who worked at Manganu when inquired about this, replied with a dismissive "sh*t happens" type of attitude (pun intended).
I think we should take this problem to the next level and make a formal report to the "Blog officiel du Parc Naturel Régional de Corse" email address: equipemontagne@parc-corse.org
They seem so keen on informing trekkers of the current trail/refuges situation that they should take this issue very seriously.
I will write an email and encourage all of you to do the same. The more we will be the more seriously they will take this problem into consideration.
Thanks to all of you
--Michele
Posted: Wed, Jul 21, 2010, 18:32